2003 Carignan Vieelles Vignes, Côtes de Thongue, France

100 WP unique

Wines that can only be made differently, but not better.

95-99 WP great

World-class wines whose depth, complexity, character and expressiveness give an unforgettable, sensual experience.

90-94 WP excellent

First class wines that are among the best of their kind. They are characterized by purity, harmony, depth and character.

85-89 WP very good

Remarkable wines with personality, expression, as well as a certain complexity and depth. They deserve every wine lover's attention.

80-84 WP good

Clean, harmonious, at best typical wines.

75-79 WP passable

70-74 WP schwach

60-69 WP insufficient

50-59 WP unacceptable